The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking

I thought I would take the opportunity to return to an article I wrote a few days ago. My blog post outlined a few of the key issues for developing creative teams. The article that inspired it from HBR[1] gave a broad definition of innovation and creativity which resonated strongly with my own experience in schools.

According to the author, Roger Schwarz[2], researchers commonly make a distinction between the definition of creativity and innovation.

Innovation involves two stages—the generation of new ideas and the implementation of the ideas. Creativity is considered to be the first stage of innovation.

I would call implementing ideas Prototyping and this typically comes after a range of ideas have been sorted, filtered and judged in different ways during Ideation. I always see a change in the energy levels during Ideation as people begin to flex their creative muscles more intensely.

Later in the article Schwarz outlines a conflict in factors that affect innovation, explaining that a different type of thinking is needed.

Creativity and the second stage of innovation require different individual skills and team structures and processes. The idea generation stage is often referred to as divergent thinking or exploration. The implementation stage is often referred to as convergent thinking or exploitation. Unless you plan to have your team hand off its creative ideas, you will need to create a team that can operate in both modes, switching among them as appropriate.

This whole area is invariably complex and more research is needed. However even from my own experience the requirements on an individual are much more intricate. I agree that we need to be in a divergent thinking state when we generate ideas, but this changes when we have to decide on which ideas are worth investing further in. It changes to a convergent thinking state. In order to identify our choices we have to narrow our field, we have to purge the ideas that don’t make the cut. For us to successfully judge a set of ideas we have to be able to converge and begin to make choices. Thinking big (divergently) and generating ideas at this stage would certainly be counterintuitive.

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking at the ideation stage is quite important and much more frequent than is suggested in the article. Idea generation is but one part of Ideation. Of course we may identify Emergent thinking as well at this stage which is exploratory and helps when we want to develop our ideas further. I see Ideation being made up of the sequence below:

  1. Generate Ideas (Divergent or Open Thinking)
  2. Explore and develop ideas (Emergent or Exploratory Thinking)
  3. Judge and shortlist (Convergent or Closed Thinking)

It is extremely useful to have a language for the thinking state or mindset needed. I would highly recommend sharing the definitions and helping others understand them. Talking explicitly about the thinking that is needed to be most successful helps signpost people to such expectations, and has helped countless teams of adults and students I have worked with. Don’t let this be a wishy washy stage, identify a process, like the sequence above and stick to it. Trust in the process.[3]

Once ideas have been explored and narrowed down then a team would move on to implementation. Taking a concept into a working or minimal viable prototype phase. Again the type of thinking here is not simply convergent as Schwarz outlines, in my opinion it is equally fluid and perhaps also made up of the combination of divergent, emergent and convergent thinking states.


  1. Harvard Business Review  ↩
  2. Roger Schwarz is an organisational psychologist, find him on Twitter @LeadSmarter  ↩
  3. And the force.  ↩

Tom Barrett

Tom is a writer, speaker and consultant. He has been sharing his thoughts on teaching, learning, curiosity and creativity on this blog for over 10 years. Drinking coffee and writing would be his idea of a perfect day.

Latest posts by Tom Barrett (see all)

Other articles you might enjoy

Leave a Reply

61 Comments on "The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking"

Notify of
avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
mhawksey
Guest
8 months 19 days ago

RT @BryanMMathers: #Ideation requires different types of thinking…
A visual thought by @tombarrett in https://t.co/3gkFssh2U4
#edtech htt…

trackback

[…] can read more about divergent thinking and the different thinking states, in my blog post: The Ebb and Flow between Divergent and Convergent Thinking. […]

trackback

[…] can read more about divergent thinking and the different thinking states, in my blog post: The Ebb and Flow between Divergent and Convergent Thinking. […]

sundevildaisy
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/jzuYeJ5ZpE #aussieed #designthinking

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/jzuYeJ5ZpE #aussieed #designthinking

MRsalakas
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

RT @robmctaggart: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/zLq9m2CQa2 by @tombarrett

robmctaggart
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/zLq9m2CQa2 by @tombarrett

aar0nloh
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

RT @BryanMMathers: #Ideation requires different types of thinking…
A visual thought by @tombarrett in https://t.co/3gkFssh2U4
#edtech htt…

SimonCorvan
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

RT @BryanMMathers: #Ideation requires different types of thinking…
A visual thought by @tombarrett in https://t.co/3gkFssh2U4
#edtech htt…

hahvenjarvi
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

RT @BryanMMathers: #Ideation requires different types of thinking…
A visual thought by @tombarrett in https://t.co/3gkFssh2U4
#edtech htt…

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

RT @BryanMMathers: #Ideation requires different types of thinking…
A visual thought by @tombarrett in https://t.co/3gkFssh2U4
#edtech htt…

BryanMMathers
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

#Ideation requires different types of thinking…
A visual thought by @tombarrett in https://t.co/3gkFssh2U4
#edtech https://t.co/nfWpg0JV7J

andy_S_crowe
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/mbW7QqFyW7

rhonimcfarlane
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/wbXWMGd2qc via @tombarrett

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 20 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/mbW7QqFyW7

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 21 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/MLcFrF037W #creativity #ukedchat

jackvgreig
Guest
8 months 21 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/q6zFzi3Cvw

3F3Lawesome
Guest
8 months 21 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/XUYExYHPiW via @tombarrett

zaanacooper
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

misterchris2014
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/QCmceGGiaq

annerotorua
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/PcBmv7T1Kx

kgerwin5
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/1kYc0xHsgz via tombarrett

groverwelch
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/QCmceGGiaq

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/QCmceGGiaq

SafinaHirji
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/q6zFzi3Cvw

MatthewOldridge
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/q6zFzi3Cvw

NatashaLowNZ
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

trackback

[…] You can read a little more about the ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking in my previous blog post. […]

ewanmcintosh
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/q6zFzi3Cvw

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/q6zFzi3Cvw

richmondETC
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/PcBmv7T1Kx

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/PcBmv7T1Kx

LollySmart
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/HkapJqPQF6

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking – The Curious Creative https://t.co/HkapJqPQF6

BloggersELT
Guest
8 months 22 days ago

via @tombarrett The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/pKdcI51JKK

tombarrett
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

@LeadSmarter Thanks for the provocation for my blog post> The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/wFijbp763F

AAIEGlobal
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/BOTwW9Xex0

toleinik
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

DT_ABQ
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

Romdhanifaten
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @iamDrWill: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/Y4z6wRwZ23 via @tombarrett

lookforsun
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @iamDrWill: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/Y4z6wRwZ23 via @tombarrett

iamDrWill
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/Y4z6wRwZ23 via @tombarrett

DrewetteCard
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

keithrchapman
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

mathtech
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

PatriceKiraly
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @sjgorman: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/9KHJyu1ys1 via @tombarrett

sjgorman
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/9KHJyu1ys1 via @tombarrett

TrillmaticRT
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

designthinkbot
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

RT @tombarrett: The ebb and flow between divergent and convergent thinking https://t.co/NCeJRZcUyr #dtk12chat #designthinking #creativity

andyvasily
Guest
8 months 23 days ago

@tombarrett Is is possible to design our own paths toward self-actualization? https://t.co/1ZBldXyQWD

wpDiscuz